Blog

Choosing between asphalt vs metal roof replacement is one of the biggest decisions homeowners face when it’s time for a new roof. Both are proven, widely used systems, but they perform very differently over the life of your home — and the right choice depends on your budget, how long you plan to stay put, and how much long-term maintenance you’re willing to take on.

At LaBrusciano Exteriors, we install both systems across Montgomery, Chester, Delaware, and Bucks counties, and we walk every homeowner through the honest trade-offs before recommending a direction. Here’s how the two compare.

Asphalt vs Metal Roof Replacement: Side-by-Side Comparison

Cost: What You Pay Now vs. Over Time

Asphalt shingles remain the more affordable option upfront, which is why they’re still the most common residential roofing material in our service area. Metal roofing costs significantly more to install, but because it can last two to three times longer than asphalt, the cost per year of service often evens out — or even favors metal — over a 40- to 50-year ownership horizon. The right answer depends heavily on how long you plan to own the home.

Lifespan and Long-Term Value

This is where the two systems diverge most. Asphalt shingles are engineered for a solid 20 to 30 years of performance, which is more than enough for many homeowners, especially those who may sell within a decade or two. Metal roofing, by contrast, is built for the long haul — a properly installed standing seam or metal shingle roof can outlast the homeowner’s time in the house entirely, making it an attractive option for those planning to stay long-term or who want to minimize future roofing costs altogether.

Maintenance and Durability

Asphalt roofs require fairly standard upkeep: keeping valleys and gutters clear, watching for granule loss, and scheduling inspections after major storms. Metal roofs are lower-maintenance by design, with fewer components that degrade over time, though fasteners and seams should still be checked periodically. In terms of raw durability, metal has a clear edge in wind, snow, and impact resistance, which matters in a region that sees the occasional severe storm.

Curb Appeal and Energy Performance

Asphalt shingles still offer the widest range of colors, textures, and architectural styles, which is part of why they remain the best roof for Pennsylvania homes with more traditional exteriors. Metal roofing has closed the style gap considerably, though, with standing seam and shingle-profile metal systems now common on both modern and historic-style homes throughout our four-county service area.

On energy performance, metal has a natural advantage: its reflective surface helps reduce summer heat gain, and cool-roof coated or light-colored metal products can meaningfully cut cooling costs. Homeowners focused on energy efficiency alongside their roof replacement should also consider how their windows perform — see our vinyl siding installation guide for Montgomery County for related exterior upgrades that improve efficiency and curb appeal together.

So, Which Is the Best Roof for Pennsylvania Homes?

There’s no universal answer — it comes down to your priorities. If you want a proven, cost-effective option with strong style flexibility, asphalt is a smart choice. If you’re planning to stay in your home long-term and want to minimize future roofing decisions while maximizing durability and energy performance, metal is worth the higher upfront investment. Our team can walk you through a personalized cost-per-year comparison based on your specific home during a free estimate.

Key Takeaways

• Asphalt shingles cost less upfront and last 20–30 years; metal roofs cost more but last 40–70 years.
• Metal roofing requires less ongoing maintenance and holds up better against wind, snow, and impact.
• Asphalt offers the widest range of colors and styles; metal offers superior energy efficiency and longevity.
• The “best” choice depends on how long you plan to stay in your home and your long-term budget priorities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is metal roofing worth the extra cost? For homeowners planning to stay long-term, yes — the extended lifespan and lower maintenance often offset the higher upfront price over time.

Does metal roofing make more noise during rain? Modern metal roofing systems are installed over solid decking and underlayment, which significantly reduces noise compared to older perceptions of metal roofs.

Can I install metal roofing over an existing asphalt roof? In most cases, a full tear-off is recommended for the best long-term performance, though this depends on your home’s structure and local building codes.

Which roof type is better for resale value? Both add value, but a newer asphalt roof and a metal roof are viewed similarly by most buyers; what matters most is that the roof is in good condition with warranty documentation available. Learn more about our process on our residential roofing services page.

Not sure which system is right for your home? Get a free roof replacement estimate from LaBrusciano Exteriors and get an honest, side-by-side recommendation.